Ashok Abeysinghe

MP Abeysinghe unrealistic on revenue estimates being unrealistic

"

…The [2023] budget presented this time is seeking the highest revenue in the entire history of Sri Lanka. Compared to last year, this year’s revenue shows an increase of 70%. In Sri Lanka, at no point has the revenue increased from year to year by more than 10%, 15% or 20%.... In the history of Sri Lanka have we ever generated a revenue figure that is in the range of LKR 3,000 billion? Every year, the revenue generated has been less than LKR 2,000 billion….

Parliament Hansard | நவம்பர் 21, 2022

false

False

உண்மைச் சரிபார்ப்புகளும்

The MP makes two claims: (1) The 2023 budget estimate has a revenue increase of 70 % from 2022, while the increases have never been over 20% in the past. (2) This revenue estimate at over LKR 3,000 billion is the highest in Sri Lankan history, and that it has never been more than LKR 2,000 billion in the past. Through these claims, the MP is arguing that the revenue target for 2023 is unprecedented and unrealistic in terms of the percentage increase and the total forecasted revenue figures. To evaluate these claims, FactCheck.lk consulted the CBSL Annual Report for 2021, the 2023 budget speech. 

Claim 1: The claim that this increase in revenue is unprecedented is incorrect. About 11 times since 1950, the nominal revenue has increased by more than the 20% maximum cited by the MP, with the highest percentage increase being 75% in 1978 (see Exhibit 1). The estimated revenue increase for 2023, from the revised revenue estimates for 2022, is 64% which is a little less than the 70% cited by the MP.  

Claim 2: As claimed by the MP the expected revenue for 2023 is the highest nominal value on record, at LKR 3,408 billion. As claimed, nominal revenue has also never exceeded LKR 2,000 billion. Even though the numbers are correct, the derived argument is incorrect. It is normal for the revenue estimate in most budgets to be the highest on record because inflation and economic growth will result in an increase of the nominal value of revenue collected, even when revenue remains the same as a percentage of GDP. To evaluate in terms of what is sensible or achievable, the comparison would be the real value (inflation adjusted value) or in terms of the percentage of GDP. On those measures the 2023 estimate is not unprecedented or an excessively high or an unrealistic estimate. (For all the years in which the real value and the revenue as percentage of GDP is higher, see Exhibit 1). 

The MP is wrong on the percentage increase of revenue being unprecedented and hugely misleading on the total value of revenue being unrealistic. Therefore, we classify the MP’s statement as FALSE.  

*FactCheck.lk’s verdict is based on the most recent information that is publicly accessible. As with every fact check, if new information becomes available, FactCheck.lk will revisit the assessment. 

Exhibit 1: Government Revenue in nominal, real, USD terms and as a share of GDP (1950 to 2023) 

*Rows highlighted in green represent the years in which revenue was higher than expected revenue in 2023.  



Additional Note

Real revenue was calculated based on the changes in the GDP deflator. For 2022, the GDP deflator was based on the latest figures released for the first nine months of 2022 by the Department of Census and Statistics. For 2023, a 30% increase in the GDP deflator was assumed based on government's projection of nominal GDP in the budget speech and with a real GDP projection of –3% from the MOF's investor presentation. Revenue in USD was calculated based on annual average USD exchange rate released by the CBSL in its Annual Report. For 2022, the exchange rate was obtained from CBSL average exchange rate spreadsheet and for 2023 the current rate of LKR 362 per USD was used.


மூலம்

Special Statistical Appendix, Central Bank Annual Report 2021,Available at; https://www.cbsl.gov.lk/en/publications/economic-and-financial-reports/annual-reports/annual-report-2021  [Last accessed 19 January 2023]   

Budget Speech 2023,Available at; https://treasury.gov.lk/api/file/192322fd-7967-49d8-ad59-6046470d68c8 [Last accessed 19 January 2023] 

National Accounts (First nine months of 2022), Department of Census and Statistics,Available at; www.statistics.gov.lk/NationalAccounts/StaticalInformation/Reports/SummaryTables/2022m6_en  [Last accessed 19 January 2023] 

Exchange Rates | Central Bank of Sri Lanka (cbsl.gov.lk) [Last accessed 20 January 2023] 

மறுமொழி இடவும்

உங்கள் மின்னஞ்சல் வெளியிடப்பட மாட்டாது